More lawyers and activists on Tuesday descended on the Attorney-General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, Mr Abubakar Malami (SAN), for his decision to remove the names of 10 soldiers named as accomplices in the kidnapping charges involving an alleged Taraba State kidnapping kingpin, Bala Hamisu, also known as Wadume, and others.
The Defence Headquarters and Army authorities kept mum over the development when contacted by one of our correspondents on Tuesday.
The Defence spokesman, Brig. Gen. Onyema Nwachukwu, and his Army counterpart, Col. Sagir Musa, failed to respond to inquiries on the refusal of the military authorities to court-martial Captain Tijjani Balarabe and his troops for their involvement in the killing of policemen who went to arrest Wadume.
They did not respond to calls nor replied to an SMS on the issue as of the time of filing this report.
The amendment to the charges announced at the Federal High Court in Abuja by the prosecuting counsel, Mr Shuaibu Labaran, on Monday, came days after the AGF took over the case from the Inspector-General of Police, Mr Mohammed Adamu, on June 3, 2020.
The AGF office cited the “bureaucracy” involved in bringing the soldiers to court and the need to allow the case to begin quickly as the reason for the amendment to the charges.
On March 16, 2020, the first time the matter was mentioned in court, Mr. Simon Lough, the lawyer who was then prosecuting the case on IGP’s behalf, complained to the judge that he was unable to produce the 10 soldiers in court because the Army authorities refused to release them.
Prompted by Lough, Justice Binta Nyako, at the March 16, 2020 proceedings issued an order directing the Chief of Army Staff, Lt.-Gen. Tukur Buratai, to release the 10 soldiers, including the army captain, for arraignment.
The AGF office took over the case from the police on June 3, 2020, and, on Monday, announced an amendment to the charges which saw the names of the soldiers removed from the charges.
The soldiers, whose names were removed in the amended charges are, Captain Tijjani Balarabe, Staff Sgt. David Isaiah; Sgt. Ibrahim Mohammed; Corporal Bartholomew Obanye; Private Mohammed Nura; Lance Corporal Okorozie Gideon; Corporal Markus Michael; L/Corporal Nvenaweimoeimi Akpagra; and Staff Sgt. Abdullahi Adamu, and Private Ebele Emmanuel.
A policeman’s name, ASP Aondona Iorbee, as well as the name of one Ahmad Suleiman (aka Dan Ball); was also struck off the charges.
Reacting to the development on Tuesday, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria, Chino Obiagwu, described the refusal of the Army authorities to release the accused soldiers and the AGF’s subsequent decision to remove their names from the charges as unjustifiable.
He said, “It is not justifiable that the military is reluctant to release the defendant soldiers. The law is clear that when military officers commit an offence under the criminal law, they must face their trial in the regular court. It is only when they commit an offence under the military law that they will be court-martialed. Nobody is above the law. There is no rational legal basis for the AGF to remove the names of the soldiers from the charges.”
Another activist and lawyer, Mr Kunle Edun, also said the AGF’s decision had raised questions that required answers.
He said although the prosecutor had the discretion to choose who to charge with an offence based on the evidence available, “he is expected to perform his prosecutorial duty in the interest of the public and justice.”
He added, “Some policemen were brutally murdered. Policemen and soldiers were indicted. Every person found to be involved in the dastard act must be arraigned for the murder of those policemen.
“That will be justice. No one is and should be seen to be above the law, and it is the duty of the Attorney General to ensure that justice is manifestly seen to be done in this case.
“Nigerians have not been told why the soldiers who are in the custody of the Nigerian Army were excluded amongst those to be arraigned for murder of the policemen.
“Was it that they were exonerated? And by whom? The AGF may need to let Nigerians know what is really happening. There are many questions that require answers to give Nigerians the assurance that the right thing is being done in this case.
“Ordinarily, it is the Attorney General of the state where the crime was committed that should be handling the murder charge, not the AGF. Why is this so? I think Nigerians need to know.”
On his part, another lawyer and private prosecutor, Mr. Tosin Ojaomo, said Malami’s removal of the names of the soldiers from the charges was tantamount to frustrating the court orders issued by the court to compel army authorities to release the soldiers.
Also, an activist, Ezenwa Nwagwu, who is the Co-Convener, Say No Campaign, said it was “important in a matter of this nature for the attorney general of the country to proactively disclose reason why some of the suspects were dropped in the public interest.”
The Executive Director, Centre for Public Accountability, Olufemi Lawson, said, “The Federal Government, through the Attorney General of the Federation, owes Nigerians further explanations, as to why the decision to drop charges against this military personnel who were practically directly involved in the summary execution of those policemen from the Inspector-General Response team, who have gone to Taraba State to effect the arrest of the notorious kidnapper, Wadume.”
Lawson added, “Several suspicions have initially arrived based on the decision of the AGF, to take over the prosecution of the matter, from the police and this latest decision confirms our fear.
“This has also raised fundamental needs to actually demand an investigation into the actual role being played by that particular Army unit in Taraba, since it is now clear, that certain interests have successfully worked to ensure that they are not prosecuted for the obviously committed crime.
“Finally, this decision will greatly demoralise that particular unit of the police that has been known to have made landmark efforts in arresting high profile criminals in our country.”
A lawyer, Mr Sani Abubakar, said although the AGF’s discretion in a criminal case could not be questioned, the public interest in the removal of the names of the soldiers from the charges was “doubtful.”
Sani said, “The AGF has absolute discretion to file charges, to withdraw charges or to discontinue charges, although the public interest, in this case, is doubtful.”
Govt must not send wrong messages to people, international observers – AI
But Amnesty International called on the Federal Government to bring all those involved in the killing of policemen in Taraba State to justice.
Commenting on the sudden withdrawal of criminal charges against the army captain and other nine other soldiers, AI Nigeria Director, Dr Osai Ojigho, said necessary steps must be taken to effectively prosecute all the perpetrators in court in a transparent manner.
This, she noted, would inspire confidence in the citizens and the international community.
She stated, “I think the government needs to be careful about the message they send out in very sensitive cases like this because one of the biggest issues that have faced the security forces in the last few years is the issue of accountability and impunity.
“It is important that when you have cases like this, that all the principles of fair hearing are upheld including the fact that the trial is open, transparent and that everyone has their day in court.”
“The Nigerian government can do a lot more to increase confidence in the people and international observers by making sure they get to the root of this particular issue,” she admonished.
Ojigho noted that the AGF ought to explain the reasons for the withdrawal of the charges against the security personnel, adding that the nation deserved to know if the government was not ready to prosecute the defendants.
She stated, “Our call would be that they should not leave any stone unturned in order to attain justice and that means, everyone that is involved or suspected to have been involved should have their day in court. The government should take the necessary steps to show that they are committed to justice.”
FG can set Wadume free – Odinkalu,
In a tweet, on Tuesday, a former Chairman of the National Human Rights Commission, Prof. Chidi Odinkalu, said the removal of the soldiers’ names from the charges, could be a precursor to setting Wadume free.
He noted that the policemen killed by the soldiers in order to free Wadume might have died in vain with the consent of Malami.
“Remember the soldiers of @HQNigerianArmy who killed @PoliceNG unit sent to arrest notorious Wadume in Taraba, NE#Nigeria, last year? It’s like they’ll walk, u know? All those police officers may have died in vain & with consent of @MalamiSan,” the tweet read.
The National Chairman of the All Progressives Congress, Mr Adams Oshiomhole, and the Edo State Governor, Mr Godwin Obaseki, on Tuesday criticised each other over the first degree certificate presented by the governor from the University of Ibadan.
Oshiomhole, in Abuja at the inauguration of the APC’s screening and appeal committees for its members contesting governorship primary in Edo State, expressed doubt over the authenticity of Obaseki’s UI certificate.
But the governor, through his spokesman, Crusoe Osagie, challenged Oshiomhole to go and confirm the authenticity of his certificate at the UI. He also said the national chairman should tell Nigerians the university he attended.
The dispute, which began last year between Obaseki and his predecessor has defied efforts of the APC governors and the African richest man, Aliko Dangote, to reconcile the two politicians.
Approach UI to confirm Obaseki’s certificate, national chair tells panel
Doubting Obaseki’s UI certificate, the national chairman on Tuesday directed the screening committee to confirm it from the nation’s premier university
Oshiomhole said, “Someone should approach the UI and end this matter once and for all. If the certificate Obaseki parades is that of the UI, find out how did he pass senate screening of those days? I’m aware that in those days when this man never dreamt of becoming a governor, every student, no matter your status or your family name, must pass screening.
“It is done every third term at the UNN (University of Nigeria Nsukka), then we ran terminal not semester programme. The final screening was in the third year, before you go in for your final year.
Tinubu denies fighting Aregbesola, Lagos APC bans groups
Police shoot robber fleeing with stolen N3.5m
Katsina anti-banditry protesters burn Buhari, Masari’s billboard
Tell us varsity you attended, Obaseki challenges Oshiomhole
30% of our US hires will be blacks – Adidas
“How comes the UI allowed him then. Did he do a remedial? which was not unlikely. These are questions. Many came in especially in education and linguistics, did remedial for one year and if the result was good, gained direct entry and graduated three years after.’’
Bayelsa gov poll has taught bitter lessons – APC national chair
While inaugurating the two committees, Oshiomhole said the APC had learnt bitter lessons from the sad experience it went through after winning the Bayelsa State governorship election only to lose at the Supreme Court on account of the submission of a questionable academic credential by the deputy governorship candidate.
He charged members of the two committees not to spare any effort in ensuring that they conducted due diligence on all claims contained in the documents submitted by all six aspirants seeking to contest the party’s primary.
He stated, “The screening is not a formality and we expect you to be very meticulous in every material in particular to protect our party so that it would not be said that we did not learn anything from Bayelsa. As you know sometimes when things go wrong, everybody sees it that NWC did not do a thorough job. So, people personalized it. They say, ‘If the chairman is thorough, if he has done his job this will not happen but that is the price for leadership.”
He urged the screening committee to interact with all those who had aspirations to contest the Edo State governorship poll.
According to him, if anybody is dissatisfied with the screening committee’s recommendations, he or she will file an appeal and it will be forwarded to the appeal committee.
NWC can reject screening result – Oshiomhole
Oshiomhole stated, “The NWC can reject the screening result. Screening committee is high court. The appeal committee is the Appeal Court and the NWC, the Supreme Court.”
Members of the two panels were drawn from the academia as well as the party’s team of legal professionals.
Members screening committee are Prof Jonathan Ayuba (Chairman), Prof Agbo Madaki, Ibrahim Zailani, Senator Aishatu Dahiru Ahmed “Binani, Dr Jane- Frances Agbu, Fort Dike while Dr Rabe Nasir will serve as secretary.
The appeal committee has Dr Abubakar Fari as Chairman, and Daniel Bwala as Secretary. Other members of the committee are Prof. Sadeeque Abba, Gbenga Olubajo, Mohammed Idris and Esther Bepeh.
The six aspirants, who have bought, completed and submitted the party’s expression of interest and nomination forms are Pastor Osagie Ize-Iyamu, Obaseki, Dr. Pius Odubu, Chris Ogiemwonyi, Osaro Odubu and Mathew Aigbuhuenze Iduoriyekemwen.
Go ahead and verify from UI, Obaseki replies Oshiomhole
But contacted by one of our correspondents, Obaseki, through his Special Adviser on Media and Communications, Osagie, said, “The University of Ibadan is perhaps the most reputable university in Africa. The University of Ibadan awarded a BA degree in Classical Studies to his excellency the governor as far back as 1979. The university is still there. If anybody feels the certificate is not credible why doesn’t the person go there to verify?
“Why are we just seeing this only in the media? Bear in mind that the Governor of Edo State, Godwin Obaseki, was among an elite corps of illustrious alumni of the university people to deliver a national alumni lecture in August 2018. Do you think such an institution will call someone who is not an alumnus to deliver such a lecture?”
Tell us varsity you attended, Obaseki challenges Oshiomhole
“Describing the allegations as baseless, he said, “We have said before, these allegations are baseless and come to think of it, which university did (Adams) Oshiomhole attend to know what the admission process is like? The responsibility of setting guidelines for admission into a university rests on the Senate of the institution. The lecturers who taught the governors are still alive and the institution is still there.”
APC, unlike Oshiomhole, believes in rule of law – Obaseki
Obaseki also reacted to Oshiomhole’s claims that the NWC would have a final say on Obaseki and others on the certificates and other issues.
Osagie, in an interview with The PUNCH, said the governor believed in the rule of law.
He said, “Our reaction is simple. We are not like Oshiomhole who is the judge and executioner. We believe in the prevalence of the rule of law. For us, that is more important than what one individual says.
“As we have always said, Oshiomhole has not hidden the fact that he has an ‘axe to grind’ with Governor Obaseki, but our hope is in the fact that our party is a law-abiding party. Our party is one that abides by its constitution and we believe that the constitution does not put all the powers in the hands of one man. On the strength of that, we know we are going to prevail.”






































































