Summary of discussions during the second public hearing of Bauchi State House of Assembly on Bauchi State Tree Planting Bill organized by the House on Committee on Forestry and Environment and presided over by the Chairman of the Committee Hon. Musa Wakili Nakwada (Bogoro Constituency) yesterday 7th August, 2020.

In his opening remarks, the Chairman House Committee on Forestry and Environment Hon. Musa Wakili Nakwada who is also sponsor of the bill thanks the participants for coming and showing much interest in the and their contributions toward the passage of the Bill.
He commended the commitment of professionals in forestry and environment who put heads together to see a very rich law comes out of the bill.
Hon. Nakwada revealed after the first public hearing many people from within and outside the State have called him to appreciate and expressed their interest and ready to contribute toward the actualization of the bill
He also appreciated the coming women to the public hearing which he said shown some degree of gender balance.

Andrew Gegam and Absolom Kushi, all former Directors of Forestry suggested that since the previous contributions are captured and some participants came with written submissions, they should be submitted to the Secretary of the Committee to save time and avoid repetitions.
Ibrahim Muhammad Bunu concurred with their opinion. He suggested that since there is existing forestry law, some people should sit down and compare what is contained in the Bill and want is contained in the forestry law so there will be no contradictions.
Suleh Saleh Yakubu observed that the title of the Bill is okay because when you look at major environmental problems such as deforestation, soil erosion, wind disaster, wild life migration can be mitigated by planting of trees. Thus the title should remain Tree Planting Bill.
James Daniel Sam a retired Director Forestry and Wild Life emphasized there should be climate change directorate in the Ministry of environment. The Assembly has already passed a law on that an the then Governor assented it.

Ishaku Shehu Mbagis on the issue of court, the only court that have jurisdiction is magistrate court as contained in the forestry law. The Bill may adopt such. He also emphasized the need of establishment of the four directorates created by law in the Ministry of Environment. They are climate change directorate, soil erosion directorate, wild life directorate.
According to him the Assembly should work to make sure the departments are in put place.
“What we have now is directorate of environment. You can’t find this anywhere.” He emphasized.
Sulaiman Zakariyya Yakubu from Climate Action Group commended the Chairman House Committee on Environment and Forestry for sponsoring the Bill.
He added that the Climate Action Group is happy with the bill saying the name of Hon. Nakwada will be written in the book of history of Bauchi State for the coming up with the vital bill which he tag is the best bill in the history of Bauchi State House of Assembly.
According to him, his group suggests that the Bill name to be cited as: “BAUCHI STATE TREE PLANTING AND SAFE FOREST BILL” because the bill incorporate the conservation of not only the trees but wildlife games and human beings inclusive.
The Group recommends that any person who violates any provision of this Law commits an offence, and is liable of conviction to fine of not more than twenty thousand naira (N20, 000) per each tree cut or to imprisonment for a term of not more than two years or both.
This is because if a person cuts one Tree, and the person cuts more their fine should differ best on the offense committed.
On the Establishment of Tree Trust Fund, Sulaiman Zakariyya Yakubu submits that the Fund shall be called “BAUCHI STATE TREE PLANTING AND SAFE FORESTRY TRUST FUND” and monies from the fine of seizure for woods, timbers, charcoal and violation of any of the laws should make part of sources fund.
Sadiya Karamba Ibrahim Bauchi State Coordinator of Climate Action Change talked about areas that the Bill is silence on such as roaming of animals on the street and climate change education I’m schools.
She suggested that the law should provide a section banning all animal roaming on the streets in the state, which will surely help communities to plant and raise trees successfully and the law should state clearly the punishments for people destroying forest reserve and parks.
Sadiya Karamba added that climate change education in schools and establishment of enlightenment forum should be included.
Professor Ahmad Sabo from Savannah Institute of Sustainable Development commended Hon Nakwada for his magnanimity, commitment and endurance toward enriching the bill.
He explained that his Institute has produced two copies; the original bill with changes and cleans copy of their own suggestions.
Presenting the suggestions of the Institute, Dr Abdullahi Chinade said that they suggest the name of the Bill should be Bauchi State Tree Planting and Enhancement of Environment Bill 2020.
The Institute also suggests purpose of the bill should include; to develop a synergy between governments, communities, individuals and corporate entities for an enhanced sustainable environment, to leverage social, economic and environmental benefits from the enhancement of forests and trees for the people of Bauchi State, to encourage the people of Bauchi State to plant and nurture trees, among other recommendations.
Other areas that the Savanna Institute of Sustainable Development made suggestions as explained by Dr Chinade include objectives of tree planting, declaration of policy, tree planting and nurturing, prohibited activity, implementing rules and regulations, supply and distribution of seedlings, maintenance of trees, separability clause, interpretation and suggested that the Bauchi State Tree Trust Fund provided by the Bill should be changed to Carbon Fund.
Nasiru Umar calls for reflection on how things are on the environment.
According to him, in this part of the country, we hate making reforms.
He added that in at the federal level, there are 7 directorates and other agencies in the federal ministry of Environment as every innovation come with new policies.
Nasiru Umar advised that to avoid conflicting roles and overlapping among sectors of the environment, the simple thing is to borrow from federal ministry of Environment.
“Lagos State borrowed a leap from Federal Ministry of Environment and they are doing great.
He there are a lot of bureaucracies politics and personal interests.” He further said.
According to Nasiru who is a representative from Savanna Institute for Sustainable Development this is the first time in history of Bauchi State that people that know environment have been gathered to talk about environment issues saying if this has been done before, we would have been talking about something else.
Issac Absolom Kushi suggests that interagency rivalry is one of the major problem in the environment sector. He suggests that there should be synergy among all sectors and departments in the environment sector.
Issac Absolom added that people around bush and forests rely on them for firewood and other needs thus the need for the Bill to provide alternatives for them.
He also emphasized on the need of relationship with the communities around forest reserves which he said is very important.
Moddibo Saleh concur with the change of title proposed by the Savannah Institute of Sustainable Development, but he environment is wide thing, since we are talking about tree planting we are talking about biodiversity.
He also suggested that reviving our tree nurseries in all the 20 LGAs is of paramount important.
Moddibo lamented on the attitude of people toward destroying forests across the State which he said is not encouraging.
He commended Savannah Institute for providing beautiful contributions. He insisted that there are some corrections in the forestry law 2017, therefore suggests that the Secretariat should go through forestry law to ensure there is no overlapping.
Ishaku Mbagi said all the technicalities are provided by the Bill but the only issue is about the issue of penalties and enforcement
Ambassador Aisha Laraba Abdullahi said this is her first time to participate in public hearing.

She thanks the House Committee on Environment and Forestry for the opportunity and expressed her pleasure with the contributions made.
“I thank all the participants for coming to contribute to enhance the environment.
‘We are thinking globally and acting globally. Other parts of the world may get interested in the Bill” Ambassador Aisha Laraba said.
In his closing remarks, the Chairman House Committee on Environment and Forestry who is also the sponsor of the Bill Hon. Musa Wakili Nakwada (Bogoro Constituency) suggests that there should be Secretariat to finalize on the bill so as to come up with a very rich bill.
He prayed that through this bill Bauchi State will become something else in term of environment
“The bill has come at the right time and met the right people to do the right thing.
” I hope that when it reached Governor will assent because he has a lot of interest in the issue of the environment.
“Management and implementation is the problem in Bauchi State. The Assembly will pass but the executive will not implement. If you go to Yankari and Sumu Wildlife Park will shed tears, the investment is their but not management.
“We have no investments more than our forests but we are not tapping from them. With this Bill, we will see what we can do.
“They will go to Lagos or London and import seedlings while we can do it here in our tree nurseries. You can see how flooding is affecting us. You can’t block waterways but create channels for the water.” Hon Nakwada explained.
At the end of the Public Hearing, Professor Ahmed Sabo, Dr Ahmed Chinade Abdullahi and Titi Yakubu from Savannah Institute of Sustainable Development, Bauchi State Coordinator of Climate Action Group Sadiya Karamba Ibrahim, Director Environmental Conservation BASEPA Aminu Ibrahim Ningi, three former directors of forestry, director forestry Bauchi State Ministry of Environment and a. representative from Bauchi State College of Agriculture are selected as the members of the Secretariat that will finalize everything on the Bill before presenting for third reading and subsequent passage into law.
They are asked to reconvene on Wednesday to complete the assignment.






































































