Summary of discussions during the public hearing of Bauchi State House of Assembly on Bauchi State Tree Planting Bill organized by the House on Committee on Forestry and Environment and presided over by the Chairman of the Committee Hon. Musa Wakili Nakwada (Bogoro Constituency) today 31st August, 2020.

1. In his opening remarks, the Chairman House Committee on Forestry and Environment Hon. Musa Wakili Nakwada who is also sponsor of the bill, goes back history lane and explained that before he joined politics and become lawmaker he was a forestry officer in the State Civil Service who worked in different Local Governments.
According to him, in the History of the Bauchi State House of Assembly, he is the first forestry officer that became member thus the reason he is trying hard to contribute his knowledge and experience to protect the environment I’m which he has so far presented two bills related to environment in the Assembly.
He added that the purpose of the public hearing on the Bull is to hear from the professionals and stakeholders in environment about the Bill because nobody has monopoly of knowledge.
Hon. Nakwada sought the contributions of the professionals by offering insights and criticisms on the Bill.
2. The first contributor, Mr James Daniel Sam a former director of forestry observed that the tree fund provided in the Bill is very good but it can be redesigned to be Bauchi State Forestry Trust Fund which will go along way with National forestry trust fund approved by the Federal Government.
“If you have such initiative here in Bauchi State, we can approach national forestry fund whenever the need arise. Therefore the State government should key in into forestry trust fund.” He said.
On the management body proposed in the Bill, Mr James opined that a governing council to be appointed by the Governor will be better.
He also suggested that auctions and compensations of forest products should be included as source in the forestry trust fund.
3. Sule Saleh Yakubu a former director forestry observed that since there are forestry sections in the Local Governments, they should be part of bodies to produce seedlings for planting by the public. Also, maintenance of the trees planted should also include local governments as they will help greatly in maintaining the seedlings planted.
4. Ibrahim Muhammad Bunu also a former director of forestry, suggested that the tittle of the Bill should be change to read Bauchi State Tree Planting and Conservation Bill because all forests reserves in the State are destroyed.
According to him when he was in service as director of forestry there were about 53 forest reserves but now they are destroyed.
He added that apart from tree planting, the bill should consider how to restore forest reserves in the State to their former status.
On the provision of tree seedlings proposed in the bill, Malam Aminu suggested that it should go beyond government and NGOs and individual participation should be considered because government can’t do everything.
He cited example with how recently an NGO donated 3000 seedlings to Bauchi State.
“We should appreciate them and incorporate and make provision in the law to make NGOs and individuals as providers of tree seedlings for planting by the public.” He further suggested.
5. Muhammad Usman Saleh a Director from BASEPA suggested that BASEPA should be included in the implementation of the bill when it becomes law.
6. Barr Haruna Ibrahim from BASEPA observed that the Bill didn’t state the court of jurisdiction for the trial of offenders.
He suggested that there should be inclusion of the court that will have jurisdiction to punish the offenders of the forestry law.
7. Professor Abdulkadir Ibrahim from Savanna Institute of Sustainable Development commends Hon. Nakwada for sponsoring the bill which he said is very important and needs everybody’s support.
According to him, the bill is more than tree planting bill.
He said it is most important bill in the State Assembly because environment is the most neglected sector in the country and it is to the detriment of the people of the country. If passed into law, the bill will saves a lot of life.
“Public hearings should be advertised on the national papers or announcements be placed in all the important places in Bauchi State, MDAs etc so that people can read and digest and come up with important position on the bill. This has not been done on this bill.” He observed.
Professor Ibrahim explained that 21st century is the era of minimum government therefore private sector and individuals should be included in tree planting and conservation of environment.
He added that government has no capacity to maintain and sustain the forests reserves thus private sector should be selected to maintain them.
“Biodiversity should prosper. Pollution can be checked by trees if you involved private sector as they can make profit and government will generate revenue.” Professor Ibrahim further suggests.
He requested that the House Committee should give special discretion to participants to submit their contributions on a specific day so that to come up with an informed position since they got short notice on the public hearing
8. Responding to the question asked on the court of jurisdiction to punish offenders, Nuhu Musa Tama Director Legal Services of BAHA asked the Barrister Haruna Ibrahim from BASEPA to study the bill and come up with suggestions to incorporate into the bill.
9. Dr Abdullahi HOD Department of Environmental Management Abubakar Tafawa Balewa University ATBU identified some errors in the bill.
He suggest that the bill should rather be titled GREENING BAUCHI state bill so that there will be other ways not only tree planting to preserve the environment.
“Even without trees we can make the state greeny. There should be more encompassing strategy to maintain the environment.
“We should reduce the use of firewood and charcoal and the rate of cutting trees will reduce.” He opined.
On the content of the Bill, the HOD suggest that the objectives of the bill should be reconsidered.
10. Professor Ahmed Sabo from Savannah Institute of Development observed that there is no issue of inclusiveness such as gender and vulnerable groups in the Bill.
He explained that Bauchi State may seek intervention from international donors and when they discovered that the issue of gender and vulnerable groups is not there in the law, that may disqualify the State.
Professor Sabo observed that the Bill contain too much that can be broken into various bills.
11. Nasiru Umar observed that there is no specifications on how many trees will make an offence and the number of tree one will cut to be fined 20,000 naira as provided by the bill.
He therefore suggested that such specifications should be made in the punishment of offenders.
12. Andrew Gegema retired director of forestry suggested that should provide that any school construction, roads constructions and all constructions that involved cutting down of trees, replacement should be mandated by the law.
13. Ishaku Shehu Director of Forestry talked on the issue on climate change.
He said that BAHA has passed a bill on the creation on directorate of climate change and erosion years ago but up to date that is not implemented.
The Director urged the Honourable House to push for implementation of the law.
14. Brig Gen BM Ibrahim observed that major stakeholders such as firewood sellers, timber and charcoal sellers are missing in the Bill.
According to him, in cutting out of such a law, these stakeholders should be taken care of.
“There are neighboring states, some of the activities are done on this borders.
“The law should capture how to relate with the neighbouring States on the issue of tree felling. Some cut trees from other states and come to Bauchi to sell the products and others can cut from Bauchi and sell in other States.” He suggested further.
15. Barr Haruna Ibrahim further observed that some sections of the bill are contradicting some existing laws of the State. He asked if the bill is passed into laws how can the new law be reconciled with the existing laws like that of BASEPA?
16. Aminu Ibrahim Ningi a Director in BASEPA suggested that the title of the bill should be change to reqd Bauchi State Reviewed Tree Planting Bill since there are other related laws.
On the charcoal production, he observed that the law didn’t state how to manage it, saying there should be alternative when charcoal production is banned.
17. A Director from Savannah Institute of Development opined that the title of the is okay because the major way of controlling environment degrading is tree planting though other greeny activities can be incorporated.
He advised that NYSC is very good partner in tree planting, therefore they should be included as stakeholders in tree planting in the Law.
18. Ibrahim Muhammad Bunu observed that BASEPA should be restricted to Local Government Headquarters headquarters and anything outside the LGs headquarters, forestry department should handle it.
He advised that the committee should take a look at the forestry law to see whether there are some contradictions and sort it out.
19. Absolom Kushi a former director forestry said that there are laws that are made since colonial era thus the bill should consider Forestry laws in operations to incorporate them.
He also suggested that modalities must be in place to ensure the execution of the law.
Kushi also suggested that people should be encouraged to plant more trees.
According to him, law is the backbone of forestry activities.
” All foreign reserves in Bauchi State are tempered with.
“The biggest forest reserve in the State Lame/Burra Games Reserve is destroyed.
“Destruction of foreign reserves largely depends on the Local Governments and local communities therefore other laws on forestry and environment should be incorporated with the Bill.
20. Dauda Zakka from BASEPA observed that the law didn’t talk about how to protect animals.
He said in Jigawa State, they made a law banning allowing animals roaming and provided punishments for offenders. He therefore suggests that same should be done in Bauchi State.
21. Further responding to some of the issues raised Director Legal Service of BAHA Nuhu Musa Tama said that though the contributions are welcomed, but contributors shouldn’t digress out of the areas related to the Bill.
He suggested that as Professor Ibrahim requested, the participants should be given more time to study the Bill and come up with an informed suggestions band reconvene.
22. Umar Yusuf Gital Esq Clerk of BAHA observed that there are so many laws governing environment, such as forestry laws, BASEPA law, grazing and cattle route law, wildlife law etc.
He therefore opined that the laws should be brought together and be studied so as to avoid overlapping and conflicting provisions.
The Clerk cited example with a law that gives Local Government chairman power to issue license to fell tree. He opined that such particular provision should be reexamined, amended or completely removed.
23. In his closing remarks the Chairman of the Occasion, Hon. Musa Wakili Nakwada explained that environment is very vast, and the bill cannot cover that’s why the it concentrates on one area.
“BASEPA is under Ministry of Environment, it has many works to do beyond planting of trees. If BASEPA concentrate on tree planting. what will other agencies be doing?
“There use to be conflict between BASEPA and forestry department but since the goal is one; to protect environment such conflicts shouldn’t have arise.” He said.
Hon Nakwada pledged that they sit down and come up with modalities to control the conflicts and rivalry between the environment agencies.
“Some reserves are said to be under tourism but tourism have no business with forests and wild.
” We must resolve these overlapping and conflicting responsibilities.” Hon Nakwada assured.
The Chairman House Committee on Forestry and Environment called on all stakeholders to come together to protect forests reserves because people are busy destroying them.
According to him tree planting will help but wondered how Government has bee talking about tree planting and now it’s almost September nothing is done, saying this is not feasible.
Hon. Musa Wakili Nakwada advocated for one man one tree policy, saying of everybody will plant one tree in Bauchi slState, in years to come Bauchi State will be great in term of environment.
He also encouraged the establishment of orchards by individuals which he said will help a lot in protecting the environment.
The Chairman lamented that professionals are not employed in BASEPA and forestry department.
He said most of the people employed are secondary schools leavers while there are many graduates but they are not employed.
According to him it is better to employ 10 graduates with specialization in environment and forestry than to employ hundred secondary schools leavers.
The lawmaker further suggested that there should be a forum that stakeholders will meet for discussing issues relating to our environment.
Hon. Nakwada vowed that the Assembly will remove any law that give local government chairman power to issue license to fell tree.
Finally the Chairman asked the professionals and other participants to study the Bill so as to come up an informed suggestions and reconvene on Monday next week.







































































