Summary of discussions during the Bauchi State House of Assembly’s public hearing on proposed Violence Against Persons Prohibition Bill organized by House Committee on Women Affairs today, 18th June, 2020:
1. The Public Hearing was attended by Speaker Rt Hon Abubakar Y Suleiman, Deputy Speaker Hon Danlami Ahmed Kawule, Minority Leader Hon. Bakoji Aliyu Bobbo, Chairman House Committee on Women Affairs Hon. Wanzam Muhammad, officials of WARDC, Civil Society Organizations, religious organizations, nongovernmental organizations, traditional rulers, ministries, departments and agencies, press, legal practitioners and various individuals.

2. In his opening remarks, Speaker Rt. Hon. Abubakar Y Suleiman said it is no longer news in Nigeria that the incidences of violence against the vulnerable people in the society is growing astronomically high.
He added that sexual assaults against minors have became alarming in all parts of the country including Bauchi State and sadly the extant laws are by far inadequate to deter the perpetrators of this immoral and devilish act of human degradation.
According to the Speaker, as representatives of the people, they are duty bound to introduce legislations that can tame the ongoing scourge being perpetrated by some ungodly adults after listening the cries of minors, parents and community leaders.
“To curtail this ugly trend, I had the honour of presenting this bill. This public hearing is an apt culmination of the effort we started.
“Our presence here, despite the threat of covid-19 pandemic is a clear testimony of the importance and urgency of the task before us.” He said.
3.The Bauchi State Focal Person of Women Advocates Research Development Center (WARDC), Mrs Mary Ann Emmanuel commended the Bauchi State House of Assembly for their patriotic zeal to domesticate VAPP in Bauchi State. She pledged to continue to partner with the legislative arm to end all form of violence against persons.
4. Amina Garuba Ahmed a Senior Magistrate in Bauchi State, spoke on jurisdiction on cases on Violence against persons as captured in the bill which is granted to only high courts of State.
She opined that if only the State courts have jurisdiction to entertain the cases, many people will be denied justice.
“High courts are centred in the State Capital. The law is supposed to be for everybody. People in the rural areas should have access to the law. If only high courts of Bauchi State have jurisdiction many citizens will be denied the benefits of the law.” She added
Magistrate Amina proposed that magistrates courts should be granted jurisdiction because they are more closer to the common man.
She is also commended the inclusion of Violence Against Persons Prohibition fund in the bill because many indigent persons don’t have money to get lawyers. The fund will help them to have access to justice.
5. Commissioner of Women Affairs Hajiya Hajara Gidado represented by Permanent Secretary of the Ministry Ahmed Shehu Lame lamented on the rise of cases of rape among various class of people.
She recalled some rape cases in many parts of the country including that of a father who raped his two daughters.
The Commissioner urged parents to redouble efforts in taking care of children their children so that they will be protected against such violence.
6. Dr. Muhammad Mujitaba Abdulkadir Secretary Abdulkadir Islamic Resource Centre Bauchi and a lecturer from College of Legal and Islamic Studies Misau who represented Islamic bodies said they have gone through the bill and they testify that it didn’t collide with Islamic injunctions.
He plead that whenever such laws will be made, they should be written according to the teachings of two major religious of the country; Islam and Christianity since people believe in religious and traditional teachings the most.
Dr Muhammad advised that more awareness should be established through religious leaders and traditional rulers by engaging them in seminars and workshops so as to sensitize people about the law and the effects of the violence against persons.
7. Alhaji Garba I Ibrahim Sarkin Yalwan MuAllahyidi who spoke on behalf of traditional rulers in Bauchi State said traditional leaders are pained by the growing cases of rape in the their communities.
He said they receive cases of rape and other violence against persons almost on daily basis
According to the monarch the VAPP law came at the right time because it will help them in reducing the cases.
He commended the State Assembly in their efforts to sanitize the society.
8. Maigari Sani Isah Executive Director Centre for Community Empowerment urged the House to look at part two of the bill that talked about punishment of offenders. He cited example with the section that talk about abandonment of children and spouses which he said is a very rampant attitude in the society. The punishment is three years imprisonment or five thousands naira fine.
Maigari Sani adds that incomplete offences such as attempt, aiding, inciting, abating should be punished vis-a-vis the actual offence.
“An attempt to commit an offence should have half punishment of the substantive offence. This principle should go across the offences. All attempts to commit any offence should have half punishment of the substantive offence.” He suggested.
9. Elizabeth James Executive Director Child Foundation and member of VAPP working committee observed that the punishment of female genital mutilation which says four years imprisonment or option of fine 200, 000 thousand naira should be reviewed because there should not be option of fine as genital mutilation is a great offence against girl child.
“It cripples the life of a girl, it can lead her having VVF. People will continue with the offence because they can afford to pay the fine.
10. Shafa’u Ladan Yusuf, Chief Magistrate and State President of the National Council of Women society said the primary legislation that’s is enacted to take care of gender based violence and other violence is penal code law and the penal code of Bauchi has been in existence for over 20 years and thus it’s inadequate.
“For example in the offence of rape penal code of Bauchi State gave only the maximum which is life imprisonment with option of fine which allowed tthe judge to impose anything lower which can be two month or one year or anything.
“Seeing the inadequacy of the law, later this House enacted a law which is controversial, a law to criminalize kidnapping, cattle rustling, rape and other related purposes as if rape, kidnapping and cattle rustling are new offences. They are already been penalized by penal code which is not repeal and new law has been enacted on the offences that are already penalized.
“The laws are there being used together. If I like as prosecutor I can take first accuser under penal code and take another offender to same court under the other law. In this kind of situation there are three boys from Bakaro who were taken court and convicted in court and are languishing in prison for life imprisonment. The same court sentenced somebody that committed the same ofdence under the penal court to prison for six years.
“We may have the same issue with VAPP law. If care is not taken we will have three laws talking about same offences with different punishments.” She narrated.
Magistrate Shafa’u asked the House to change section 35 of the bill by repealing other laws related to the offences.
According to her to should be stated in the VAPP law, thar provision of penal code law and anti kidnapping law are repeal or should be repealed.
11. Yusuf Musa Lasta Gumau representative of National Human Rights Commission said the commission commends the Speaker and all members of Bauchi State House of Assembly for their effort to pass the law on violence against persons.
He opined that there should not be option of fine because of the gravity of the offence.
On jurisdiction, he said if it is restricted to high courts, perpetrators will go unpunished because the cases happen in remote areas.
Lasta Gumau also commended the House for putting VAPP fund in the bill to help less privileged who cannot afford to take lawyers and other logistics.
12. Diken Musa Adejo A director in CAN who represented Christian organizations said Christians in Bauchi are in full support of VAPP law.
According to him, Christianity does not support violence against persons.
He lamented the increasing cases of rape and other forms of violence.
The Director hoped that the bill will be passed and assented.
He also called on BAHA and WARDC to engage in massive mobilization and sensitization on rape and other forms of violence.
13. Sadiya Ilyasu Muhammad from ArewaMeToo movement said they support the domestication of the VAPP law which gave room for compensation to victims apart from other forms of punishments to offenders.
She pledged to give support to BAHA and support all victims of such violence where necessary.
14 Maikudi Grace Executive Director Association of Orphans and Vulnerable Children in Nigeria suggested that the parents that hide the cases of rape and refuse to give consent for justice to take its course on offenders who raped their children should also be punished.
15. Amina Mubarak Ahmad Gumau from Arewa Not Normal Group talked about sections of the bill hat talk about female genital mutilation.
She said that the matter is controversial because some religions and cultures approve it.
Amin however highlighted that there are four types of female genital mutilation; type 1,2,3 and 4.
According to her, type 3 and 4 are more dangerous because it causes health hazards like vvf and painful sexual intercourse.
She suggested that religious leaders and traditional rulers should be called for a dialogue to look at all the four types of female genital mutilation and how the law will act on them.
16. Yusuf Salim, Coordinator of Almajiri Child Right Initiative observed that most of the discussions centred on man raping a woman forgetting the fact that women also rape men.
Deputy Speaker Hon Danlami Ahmed Kawule corroborated and gave a highlight on the matter saying that there are many cases of young men being raped. There are female teachers and caregivers that spoiled boys.
In his response, Speaker Rt Hon Abubakar Y Suleiman said rape in the bill didn’t discriminate against any gender. It is unambiguously defined in the bill. It can be she raping or he raping.
17. Comr Jaafar Ibrahim Dass from Bauchi State Forum for Good Governance observed that issue of enforcement is a serious issue when laws a made. He wondered why security agents are absent at the public hearing since they the agencies saddled with the responsibility to enforce laws.
He observe that all the punishments in the bill have an option of fine.
Comrade Jaafar suggested that where there will be an option of fine of 100k, it should be a benchmark depending on the severity of the case, to be between 100k to one million naira so that at the discretion of the Judge he can jack up the fine depending on the circumstances of the case.
“Looking at the way and manner dispensation of justice is suffering, in relation to time, the bill should earmark a timeframe where all cases on violence against persons should be dispensed so that the victims should not be suffering for a very long time without the perpetrators of the offence being brought to book.” He opined.
Jaafar alsi suggested that those who stigmatized victims of violence should also be punished.
18. The Speaker directed that those who still want to submit a written memorandum, should do so from today to Monday, 21st June, 2020.
19. In his closing remarks, Chairman House Committee on Women Affairs Hon. Wanzam Muhammad thanked all participants for their contributions. He said the State House of Assembly takes the bill very serious because it affects all families.
He pledge that the House will make use of all the contributions given by the participants.







































































